UTOPIA Proving a Popular Scapegoat for City Revenue Issues

A lot of cities have been talking property tax hikes lately, and the most certain thing about all of the proposals is that elected officials are going to look for someone or something to blame. In UTOPIA member cities, blaming the fiber network has become the easy go-to solution, especially since so many mayors and city council members weren’t involved in the original decision. The problem, however, is that this blame is completely paving over a deeper problem of city tax structure that’s boring, doesn’t fit the anti-UTOPIA narrative, and is a much larger problem for city budgets. Let’s take the examples of West Valley City, Orem, and Taylorsville, the latter of which is not a UTOPIA member city. In all three cases, they’ve called for large (as a percentage) property tax increases to make up for lagging sales tax revenues. So if UTOPIA is the cause of property tax increases, why would a non-member city need to more-or-less do the same thing?

When you dig deeper, you’ll find that all three cities have worked very hard to make themselves retail shopping destinations. Orem has pumped a lot into University Mall. West Valley did the same thing with the Valley Fair Mall (albeit with the additional burden of having a less-than-stellar reputation for public safety). The Family Center is Taylorsville’s retail play. All of the cities have said that the sluggish economy is to blame for flagging sales tax revenues, yet the greater Utah economy has been doing fairly well. None of the cities, however, seem to have counted on continued growth in online sales to drain their sales tax revenues.

This is the core problem: sales tax revenues are a volatile source and have been on a downward trend for well over a decade, but these cities seem to be blissfully unaware of it. Instead of recognizing the long-term structural problems associated with attaching on-going costs to what has effectively become one-time revenue booms in good years, cities have tried to be a “last man standing” in the retail field as it experiences significant contraction. The property tax increases are really nothing more than finally realizing that you can’t hitch too much of the city’s on-going operations to a volatile source of income. You’re going to see a lot more of this rebalancing in the coming years from most cities, and especially those with large retail centers, as property taxes tend to be a lot more stable. So why blame UTOPIA, an expense, for what is effectively an issue with an improperly-balanced tax base?

For starters, it’s easy to go along with the perception of popular opinion. UTOPIA gets a lot of negative press because of the cost associated with it, even though the cost is relatively small. (Consider that UTOPIA comprises just under 3.2% of the Orem city budget, and that assumes both zero budget growth and that UTOPIA never produces enough revenue to pay back any of the bond, both extremely unlikely possibilities.) Since nobody has done much in the way of public opinion polling among member city residents to see what the actual feelings about the network are, city council members who are relatively new to the issue are going off of their anecdotal evidence of who’s yelling at them the most. Since people angry about the network are more likely to show up to city council meetings, they get a non-representative view of public opinion. It’s the same problem a business has of angry customers talking to far more people than happy customers.

It’s also really hard to explain tax policy in simple sound bites. As much as people hate property taxes, it’s an exceptionally stable source of revenue. While sales taxes can often attract revenues from outside the city, it’s subject to to the whims of the greater economy. Sales taxes are often very small micro-transactions, so many people don’t really realize just how much sales tax they’re paying. Compare that to the property tax bill where you see a statement of just how much you owe. If it were possible to tally up the total sales taxes you pay to the city, you’d probably be surprised just how much it is. It’s also a Good Thing(TM) to tie recurring costs to more stable revenue sources. Now how do you take all of that information, condense it into a 20-second response, and convey it to someone who’s more angry than reasonable? It’s exceedingly difficult, so most elected officials won’t bother trying, especially when the next wave of ill-informed constituents is just around the corner.

It also provides cover for other city expenses. Orem is also proposing a 2% increase in city employee salaries after several years of wage freezes and significant costs in the new Center for Story performing arts complex. (UPDATE: I read the Daily Herald story incorrectly. The Center for Story is funded via a voter-approved tax levy, but the maintenance comes from the general fund. Even that may be covered by a private donor.) While these items can equally be blamed for most or all of the property tax hike, it’s a lot easier to say “my predecessor did it” and act as if you have no choice rather than own your own spending. It’s a dishonest move meant to shift ownership, and it’s a lot easier than trying to explain why these things are necessary.

There is a silver lining with the current blame being assigned to UTOPIA: it’s a single-use excuse. The payments increase at under the rate of inflation, so even if the full bond has to be paid with tax pledges, it will be an ever-shrinking portion of the budget. (Using the previous Orem example, we’re talking payment increases of about $56K annually a few years from now. Compare that to the total city budget of $88.7M.) It’s also watered down substantively by other cities who are proposing similar property tax increases but are not members of UTOPIA.

For more on Orem’s property tax increases, read the full article at the Daily Herald.

Tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to UTOPIA Proving a Popular Scapegoat for City Revenue Issues

  1. The problem that politics is setting is growing more and more each day. Outside of this, take a look at business’ with MASIIVELY RECORD BREAKING PROFITS yet no one can hire anyone? Or that Trax could have goten a grant for $5 million, which would have taken them into Utah County, turned it down for unkown reasoning?

    Its getting sad to be involved in all the ways that polotics are screwing the average folk. While, right now, its usually the Republicans the Democrats have their issues as well. Just not so far reahing into the average persons affairs. Its time the people start demanding more honesty from their parties and officials. Take a look at the rosters of groups like the ‘Utah Tax Payers Association’ and if your congressman or senator (hint, hint Mr. Hatch) is involved or their families are… phone them and call them on their BS.

    We cant just email either. Thats not yet considered official record, as anyone can make a thousand Yahoo mail accounts. Either write in or call them. Make sure its a mthod they cant turn around and claim didnt happen. Get involved and get things done, or oust em for not complying tho the constituent concenscus. If its not official record you may have well just went outside and yelled it in the wind!!

  2. Jimmy says:

    Interesting that the newspaper article says regarding Orem that “The heart of the budget is UTOPIA.” How is a $2.8 million expense the heart of an $88 million budget? Like you said Jesse, it’s just seems like an easy scapegoat.

  3. charlesH says:

    A couple of thoughts.

    1) Orem employees need to take a pay cut (not 2% increase). Seems they have been shielded from the recession by using the city’s saving account. Meanwhile I have seen by retirement income (from savings) decline by 50% in the last 6 yrs and my children, two of which are recent college grads struggle to find employment above $10-15/hr (reportedly 50% of recent college grads are unemployed/underemployed).

    2) I understand the resentment for Orem residents paying for Utopia when they don’t use the service. I too resent paying and not being able to signup. Utopia needs to drastically increase users in available neighborhoods. Ever heard of sunk cost? Assuming a $60/m bill $30 for the service and $30 for the fiber how about offering a discount for the fiber portion of the bill. $10? $20? anything is better than nothing.

    • Jesse says:

      UTOPIA has a plan to increase users in available neighborhoods. You may recall that a few months ago, UTOPIA started offering a new lease option in neighborhoods where the fiber is on the curb, but the actual service address isn’t yet hooked up. This is in addition to the “buy your connection” option where you can either pay up-front (and get an immediate discount on service) or over as long as 20 years (which is about the same as existing users now pay).

      • charlesH says:

        I think they need to be more aggressive. Anything they can get for the sunk cost of the fiber to the curb is better than they are getting now.

        Orem city/taxpayers are paying for fiber to the curb sunk cost.. Who is in charge of Utopia marketing in Orem? What is their name and contact info?

        • Jesse says:

          Gary Jones is the VP of marketing. He can be reached at gjones@utopianet.org or 801-613-3800, the main number at UTOPIA. From what I understand, they’ve been getting so much incoming interest in Orem (over 15K contacts since January 1) that they’re using that as the basis of determining where to determine where to conduct on-the-ground marketing.

    • charlesH says:

      Orem City Salaries
      17 Orem employees are paid over $140,000
      40 Orem employees are paid over $120,000
      115 Orem employees make over 100,000
      180 Orem employees are making over 90,000

      Orem City Salaries from Utah’s Right.com link above
      Paul B. Johnson City Attorney $185,123
      Bruce W. Chesnut City Manager $184,457
      Stanford Sainsbury Development Serv Dir $184,022
      Richard B. Manning Adm. Services Director $173,378
      Michael J. Larsen Public Safety Dir $171,164
      Louise G Wallace Library Director $166,261
      Stephen H. Clark Public Safety Div Mgr. $163,702
      Robert S. Conner Public Safety Div Mgr $162,370
      Ned R. Jackson Public Safety Div. Mgr. $160,295
      Ernesto Lazalde Inform Tech Div. Mgr. $156,307
      Karl R. Hirst Recreation Director $156,238
      Greg Stephens Deputy City Attorney $154,751
      K. Ed Gifford City Engineer $151,126
      Stephen E Weber Maintenance Div Mgr. $149,935
      Marvin Scott Gurney Public safety Div. Mgr. $149,343
      Jeffrey W Pedersen Senior Budget Analyst $144,917
      Chris R Tachinkl Public Works Dir $143,402
      Philip C Murphy Police Lieutenant $138, 108
      Gary K. Giles Police Lieutenant $137,569
      Todd Mallinson Police Lieutenant $138,720
      Bruce G Hammond HR Div Manager $134,466
      Guy N.Gustman Police Lieutenant $132,653
      Kevin Kemp Fire Battallion Chief $132,604

  4. Pingback: Local groups whipped Oremites into an unhinged frenzy | Free UTOPIA!

  5. Pingback: The long knives come out: Tribune articles on UTOPIA | Free UTOPIA!

  6. Earl Gray says:

    Our son Brent, lives in Brigham City UT, 84302, is very happy with the speed. He desires that his father, Earl L. Gray, also have UTOPIA; therefore we desire to submit this request.
    /s/ Earl L. Gray

  7. Pingback: If UTOPIA is a boat anchor, why is Orem the only one sinking? - Free UTOPIA!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>