Did UTOPIA just out-epic Provo?

There’s not a lot of details out about the proposed public-private partnership between UTOPIA and Macquarie, but it’s already looking like Provo’s deal with Google Fiber is about as raw as I thought it is. Here’s a breakdown of how the two deals differ:

UTOPIA/Macquarie iProvo/Google
Contract length 30 years 7 years
Investment per address ~$2,000 ~$500
Revenue Sharing Yes (unknown amount) None
Open Access Yes No

So, to be clear, UTOPIA’s proposed deal with Macquarie will bring a longer commitment, more money, and revenue sharing with the cities while preserving open access. In this light, Google Fiber seems like epic’s cheap knock-off. Provo, you just got punked.

Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Did UTOPIA just out-epic Provo?

  1. Pingback: Hans V. Anderson Jr.’s Curious Definition of Failing - Free UTOPIA!

  2. Ronald D. Hunt says:

    Really hope this goes through, this looks to be a good deal, atleast from what is known so far.

    I have been stuck on comcast for the last couple years, After Centurylink toke over qwest and started oftering line speeds beyond what the lines can handle here the copper from the node service(FTTN) dsl connections have become so unreliable that they can be called a competitive option only in jest.

    Currently pay $80 month for 50meg service(no tv just internet), would much rather that go into Utopia.

    Would be nice to get Xmission back I really miss their fantastic network.

  3. Greg Stolworthy says:

    I will be the first person in line to get this when it’s available in my area; I check for it nearly every day. For the same amount i pay comcast I will easily be able to get gigabit speeds. And if I choose to go with the cheaper option, I’ll still have better speeds than comcast, and save more than 50% of what I pay now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>